Chinese justice seeps into Canada

| | |

This story in yesterday's Post by Kevin Libin, about the Chinese consulate in Calgary forcibly holding a Tibetan protester for nearly an hour, is growing into a international incident. RCMP are now investigating the conduct of the consulate staff. Kevin will be on Rob Breakenridge's radio show imminently to discuss it.

I believe in property rights, and I believe that trespass is a tort, and can even be a crime. I also believe in diplomatic immunity, even for diplomats from cruel regimes like Communist China. But if a Tibetan youth did break the law in Canada, it's for Canadian police and prosecutors to deal with -- not some brutish Chinese apparatchik, who thinks he's still back in Tiananmen Square, meting out Chinese-style "justice".

I understand that the youth in question doesn't want to make a fuss, out of fear for his family back home. Fair enough, but too bad -- I think he'd have a helluva case against the consulate for false imprisonment, assault and battery. If the staff who bullied him were locally-hired, he might be able to proceed against them. If they were Chinese nationals, they'd likely be exempt, and I doubt the case could proceed against the government of China itself. But even filing such a doomed lawsuit would be a well-deserved black eye for the world's biggest bully.

P.S. I love this suggestion aired by the National Review's John Derbyshire. I know it would never happen; but if Taiwan did declare independence on the first day of the Beijing Olympics, what would China do?

UPDATE: Kevin did a good thought experiment on the radio: what would be the media reaction if it were the U.S. consulate that seized an anti-U.S. protester and handcuffed and held him in their office for an hour before releasing him to Calgary police? 

 

Donate to fight the HRC


"This organization is not a registered non-profit organization.  Donations to this organization are not tax deductible for federal income tax purposes."

Sign up for the mailing list

Name:

Email:

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Ezra Levant published on March 19, 2008 8:10 PM.

The importance of Rick Mercer's "rant" was the previous entry in this blog.

"A great deal of anger has been expressed" is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Blogrolls





Blogging Tories